Perfection vs. Presence: The Real Benefits of Performing Live
- Gavin Stewart
- Aug 7
- 3 min read
Updated: 3 days ago

I always encourage my students to perform— whether it’s in a small recital, a school concert, or a community event. In today’s world, where recordings offer near-perfect versions of music at our fingertips, it might seem old-fashioned or even unnecessary to get up in front of people and play. After all, isn’t the goal to play flawlessly, to sound exactly like the recording?
But here’s the thing: being perfect isn’t really the point of live music. In fact, striving for perfection alone can sometimes take away from the deeper joy and meaning of performing. Let me explain why.
Recordings vs. Live Performance: Different Experiences
With modern technology, recordings allow musicians to polish their performances to a level of precision and clarity that’s simply impossible on stage. You can record multiple takes, edit mistakes, and create a sound that’s consistent every time someone presses play.
Yet, this perfection has a cost. As discussed in recent music studies, recordings freeze music as a fixed object — a “chrysalis,” if you will — preserving only one version of the sound, separate from the live context. The unpredictable, dynamic, and collaborative nature of music-making disappears behind the glass of the recording studio.
Live concerts, on the other hand, are like butterflies — ever-changing, fluid, and vibrant. Every performance is unique because it happens in a specific place, time, and social context. Musicians respond to the audience’s energy, the acoustics of the venue, even their own emotions in the moment. Small imperfections aren’t flaws; they’re part of the authenticity and humanity of music.
Why Shared Experiences Are Valuable
When you perform live, you’re telling a story, communicating feelings, and creating a special connection with your listeners. This shared experience is something recordings can’t fully replicate.
Before the 20th century, music was usually part of social gatherings or religious ceremonies, embedded in the cultural fabric of everyday life. The concert stage, as we know it, is a relatively modern invention, emphasizing performance as an event in itself.
Today, many listeners experience music mainly through recordings, which can sometimes turn music into background noise or a “commodity” to consume passively. But live performances demand attention, invite emotional engagement, and foster a sense of community between performers and audience.
Embracing Imperfection as Part of Growth
No concert is perfect. There will be nerves, missed notes, timing hiccups. And that’s okay. These moments teach resilience, deepen musicianship, and remind us that music is a living art form.
In fact, studies highlight how performers’ self-awareness has increased because they can listen to recordings of themselves and reflect. But nothing replaces the thrill and learning that happens on stage.
So, Why Should You Perform?
You grow as a musician: Each performance helps you understand your music and yourself better.
You connect with others: Sharing music live creates powerful emotional bonds.
You contribute to tradition: By playing in concerts, you keep alive a centuries-old practice that values spontaneity and human connection.
You have fun: Beyond all the technical stuff, music is about joy and expression.
Final Thoughts
While recordings have revolutionised how we access and appreciate music, they don’t replace the magic of live performance. So don’t let the idea of being perfect hold you back. Every concert is a chance to experience music fully — with all its challenges, surprises, and rewards.
I invite you to step on stage, share your music, and be part of something truly special. Because music is not just about sound — it’s about life, connection, and moments that stay with us forever.
Comments